Car Craft Magazine Homepage Car Craft
Facebook Click here to find out more!

Camshafts Internal Combustion Engine - Three-Way Cam Lobe Shootout

Are Roller Cams Worth It? Should You Just Run A Flat Tappet? We'll Show You In Our Shootout.

Photography by
Camshafts Internal Combustion Engine Camshafts
Valvesprings need to be carefully matched to the specific camshaft in order to obtain maximum advantage from the cam. This is a dual spring with both an inner and outer spring plus a small, flat wire damper that is not counted as a spring.
Camshafts Internal Combustion Engine Camshafts
Valvesprings need to be carefully matched to the specific camshaft in order to obtain maxi

Why You Need To Upgrade The Valvesprings
This chart is easy to understand once you know a little bit about valvesprings. Load at installed height refers to the amount of pressure in pounds created by the spring with the valve closed at a given installed height. The installed height is the distance from the bottom of the retainer to the spring seat location on the cylinder head. Load at maximum lift is the pressure created by the spring across the nose of the cam at its greatest valve opening. The spring rate is the amount of load in pounds created for every inch of travel the spring is compressed. If you know the load at both the closed and open points, you can determine the rate. Subtract the installed load from the open load and then multiply by the lift ratio (lift ratio = 1 divided by the max valve lift). Using the 939 spring as an example: 420 - 167 = 253 x 1.85 [1 1/4 0.540 lift = 1.85] = 468 pounds per inch (lb/in) spring rate. Coil-bind refers to the height of the spring when it is fully compressed. It's critical that the engine builder allow a minimum of 0.060 inch of clearance to coil-bind. We chose spring pressures higher than Comp's recommendations to ensure that the valvetrain would not go into valve float during testing.

Note the radical increase in seat pressure for the mechanical roller spring application. The hydraulic flat-tappet and roller springs both use a seat load of roughly 160 pounds. But when we get to the mechanical roller springs, the seat pressure jumps to 240 pounds at the same installed height. That's a 50 percent increase in seat pressure and a 59 percent increase in load at max lift. This is necessary in order to fully control the much higher acceleration rate and valve velocities achieved by the mechanical roller lobe working on the valves. As these opening and closing rates increase, they create much larger forces on the valve that must be controlled by the valvesprings.

Valvespring Load @installed ht. Load @ max lift Rate (lbs./in.) Coil-bind(in.)
Comp PN 928, dual 153 @ 1.900 330 @ 0.500 354 1.160
Comp PN 939, dual 167 @ 1.900 420 @ 0.540 468 1.225
Comp PN 943, dual 240 @ 1.900 557 @ 0.575 551 1.150    
Enjoyed this Post? Subscribe to our RSS Feed, or use your favorite social media to recommend us to friends and colleagues!

*Please enter your username

*Please enter your password

*Please enter your comments
Comments:
Not Registered?Signup Here
(1024 character limit)
Car Craft