Car Craft Magazine Homepage Car Craft
Facebook Click here to find out more!

Chevy vs. Ford vs. Mopar - Battle Of The Titans

Head To Head

By The Car Craft Staff, Photography by Henry De Los Santos, Marko Radielovic, Terry McGean, The Car Craft Staff

Wheel to WheelSince the only people who race dynos are magazine writers, we decided to plug all three power curves into the Racing Systems Analysis (RSA) Quarter Pro dragstrip simulation program. We have over a dozen years of experience using this program to evaluate quarter-mile potential with various power combinations.

The beauty of a computer simulation is that we can "bolt" all three engines into the same theoretical car. We chose a car that shifted at 6,500 rpm and spec'd out at 3,400 pounds using a 2,500-stall converter with 5 percent slippage, a three-speed automatic trans turning a 3.73 rear gear, and 26-inch-tall sticky rear tires. To no one's surprise, the simulations followed the power curves, but the interesting thing was the subtle performance difference between the Chevy and the Mopar. Despite the Chevy's obvious power advantage, the simulation showed a quarter-mile e.t. difference of only 0.03 second and 0.60 mph (11.74/117 for the Chevy and 11.78/116.4 for the Mopar). The e.t. difference could easily be the differential in reaction time, making it a true heads-up contest. The Ford cranked out a respectable 12.19/111.9 mph pass. All runs were simulated at sea level on a 72 degree F day with a barometer of 29.92.

Engine e.t. Speed 60-ft.
Chevy 11.74 117.00 1.70
Mopar 11.78 116.40 1.71
Ford 12.19 111.90 1.72

With a Little Help From Our FriendsA project like this is not only very time-consuming but also downright expensive. First of all, we'd like to acknowledge JMS Racing Engines for the time, consideration, and effort that went into a battle of this scope.

Of equal importance are the several layers of help that came directly from Crane Cams and the crew from Daytona Beach, Florida. Several other companies also contributed to this exercise and we also want to note their involvement.

ChevroletAt first blush, most onlookers would immediately assume that the clear advantage in our competition would be had by the Chevy. It seemed obvious given the two primary constraints of the shootout-use a factory iron head and don't spend more than $2,500-since the best parts at the best prices are available for the Chevy. But the times, they are a changin', and cheap, effective hardware is no longer the sole property of the small-block Chev. As a result, Team Chevrolet (in this case, me) soon found that victory would not be had without a fight.

The SpecsDisplacement: 355 ciCompression: 10.4:1Cam type/specs: Crane PowerMax hydraulic flat-tappet, 244/252-degrees duration @ 0.050-inch valve lift, 0.516/0.525-inch liftCylinder heads: Scoggin-Dickey-prepared cast-iron GM Vortec, 64cc chambers, 1.94/1.50-inch valves, Z28-style valvesprings, LT4 retainersInduction: Edelbrock Performer RPM Air-Gap, dual-plane intake, 750-cfm Speed Demon carbHeaders: Hooker Super Competition, 151/48 inchesCost: $2,188.84

Dyno DayAfter we filled the crankcase with 10W30 oil, JMS dyno guy Robert Hendrix fired the engine and ran it around 1,500-2,000 rpm to break in the cam for the better part of a half-hour. Later, the break-in lube was drained and replaced with Mobil 1 synthetic 5W30. The first pulls were partial runs to make sure everything was copacetic, though as we took the engine higher and higher in its rpm range, things were looking increasingly promising. Our stated goal had been 430 hp, and while some had scoffed, we knew we had to come at least close to that figure to best the Mopar, which we now knew had generated 418 hp.

By The Car Craft Staff
Enjoyed this Post? Subscribe to our RSS Feed, or use your favorite social media to recommend us to friends and colleagues!

*Please enter your username

*Please enter your password

*Please enter your comments
Comments:
Not Registered?Signup Here
(1024 character limit)
pjc360
ill be the first to post, mopar engines are no doubht more expensive to uprage, but if you made the sallary cap say 5000 instead of 2500 and kept stock cylinder heads as a rule the 360 would more then likely come out on top using the big magnum r/t heads and a hydraulic ROLLER cam. just my opinion although vortec heads do flow very well i think that magnum r/t heads would put up a much better fight against the vortec heads
Car Craft